Peter is a partner in the Albuquerque offices of Rothstein, Donatelli, Hughes, Dahlstrom, Schoenburg & Bienvenu, L.L.P., and has been in private practice since 1993. He specializes in complex criminal defense work in both federal and state courts.
Peter has successfully represented persons charged with a wide variety of white-collar criminal offenses involving healthcare, tax fraud, environmental defenses, National Lab security allegations, bank fraud, political corruption, child pornography, mail fraud, illegal trading in sacred tribal objects (NAGPRA and ARPA), and Foreign Corrupt Practices Act violations. He also regularly defends persons prosecuted for artistic work or religious activities protected under the First Amendment (see the Rendleman, Gonzales and Boyll cases listed in the Representative Cases section of this profile).
Peter teaches Trial Advocacy and Evidence at UNM Law School as an adjunct faculty member. For ten years, he co-authored a bimonthly column on the defense of drug cases in The Champion. He is the 2002 recipient of the Charlie Driscoll Memorial Award, the highest award bestowed by the New Mexico Criminal Defense Lawyers Association (NMCDLA). In 1984, he received the National Legal Aid and Defender Association's Defender Services Award for his work as a state public defender.
Prior positions: Chief Assistant Federal Public Defender, District of New Mexico, 1989 - 1993. Assistant Federal Public Defender, District of New Mexico, 1985 - 1989. Assistant Attorney General, State of New Mexico, 1983 - 1985. District Public Defender, 1st Judicial District, 1980 - 1983, Assistant Public Defender, 1st Judicial District, 1978-1980.
United States v. Larry Lujan 2:05-CR-00924 RB (D.N.M. 2011) (three month federal death penalty trial with life verdict returned Oct. 5, 2011.) The first federal capital case to go to trial in New Mexico since Furman v. Georgia was decided in 1972. Peter was appointed by the Court as Learned Counsel under 18 USC 3005.
Case v. Hatch 773 F. Supp. 2nd 1070, 2011 WL 1126335 (D.N.M. 2011) (22 year old murder conviction reversed based on constitutional Brady error, state supreme court's Brady analysis was contrary to clearly established federal law)
United States v. Velarde 485 F. 3d 553 (10th Cir. 2007) (granting evidentiary hearing on whether Government withheld information helpful to defense)
State v. Rendleman 134 NM 744 (2003) (finding some child photos taken by Santa Fe artist not to be covered by criminal statute and establishing, for the first time nationally, that the 1st Amendment may protect naked images of children)
US v. Hardman 297 F. 3d 1116 (10th Cir. 2002) (en banc) (finding that a member of an Indian tribe, not recognized by the Federal Government, has the right to possess eagle feathers for religious purposes)
US v. Velarde 214 F.3d 1204 (10th Cir. 2000) (Reversing conviction because Pediatrician allowed to vouch for truthfulness of child witness and not qualified to give opinion on sexual assault allegations under Daubert)
State v. Allison 129 NM 566 (2000) (reversing 1st degree murder conviction based on improper cross examination of defendant)
US v. Gonzales 957 F. Supp. 1225 (1997) (dismissing the criminal prosecution of a Pueblo man who shot an eagle for religious purposes based on the Religious Freedom Restoration Act)
US v Kennedy 955 F. Supp. 1331 (D.N.M. 1996) (failure to maintain and document training of police drug dog rendered affidavit insufficient to establish probable cause to search bags)
US v. Greenspan 26 F.3d 1001(10th Cir. 1994) (new sentencing ordered when Federal Judge refused to recuse himself after defendant accused of plotting to kill the Judge)
US v. Boyll 774 F. Supp. 1333 (D.N.M. 1991) (dismissing prosecution of non-Indian member of Native American Church for possession and importation of Peyote on religious freedom grounds)
Yale University (B.A., 1975)
Rutgers University Law School (J.D., 1978)
DISTINCTIONS AND HONORS
Selected by his peers as one of the top 25 lawyers in New Mexico - Southwest Super Lawyers (2012)
Listed in The Best Lawyers in America -Criminal Defense: Non-White Collar and Criminal Defense: White-Collar (since 1994)
Southwest Super Lawyers - Criminal Defense (since 2007)
Southwest Super Lawyers - Criminal Defense: White Collar - (since 2007)
Charles Driscoll Memorial Award, NM Criminal Defense Lawyers Association, 2002
Defender Services Award, National Legal Aid and Defender Association, 1984
State Bar of New Mexico, 1978
United States District Court, District of New Mexico, 1986
United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit, 1986
United States Supreme Court, 1993
United States District Court, District of Arizona, 1994
United States District Court, Western & Northern Districts of Texas, 1995
United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit, 1995
United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit, 1996
MEMBERSHIPS AND AFFILIATIONS
New Mexico Criminal Defense Lawyers Association (Past-President) (CLE Director 1995-2005)
New Mexico Board of Legal Specialists Recognized Specialist in Criminal Law
State Bar of New Mexico (Chairman, 1986 - 1987; Board Member, 1985 - 1988, Criminal Law Section)
National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (Vice Chair, Judiciary Reform Committee, 2002 - 2003)
PROFESSIONAL AND CIVIC ACTIVITIES
Publications: “Unspeakable Suspicions – Challenging the Racist Consensual Encounter”, The Champion, October 1993
“Survival Tips for the State Criminal Practitioner in the First Stages of a Federal Case”, The New Mexico Criminal Practice Manual, 1992
Co-author of “Controlled Substances”, a bimonthly column in The Champion, October 1993 – March 2002.
New Mexico Innocence and Justice Project - Board of Directors, 2010 -
WildEarth Guardians - Vice President, Board of Directors, 2012 -